• Aryeh Brickner

Talent vs. Management: The dumpster fire which are the Cleveland Browns

Imagine you were building a team and your choice was a group of mid-level talented employees with an outstanding manager or a subpar manager with outstanding talent, which one would you choose? A lot of people would choose the talented team with a subpar manager, but guess what, they’d be wrong. (in my humble opinion)

The perennial dumpster fire known as the Cleveland Browns entered the NFL season with high hopes built around a lot of talent. As individuals, they seemed like an outstanding group of football players. They were the talk of the off-season with some pundits even whispering the words “Super Bowl”.

But as the Browns learned the hard way, talent doesn’t trump management or in their case coaching. In a league where experience is important, they have a first-year head coach who only last year was a position coach. It’s the equivalent of taking someone in payroll and making them CEO within 6 months.

If you are putting a team together, first and foremost, find a great manager. One of the things a good manager does is ensure all the employees are working in unison towards a single goal. Often, but not always, talented people are looking out for themselves, especially if there isn’t a strong management presence above to guide them. A good manager can help cultivate talent and draw out excellence from employees. That’s also a sentiment echoed in the sports world. “He gets so much out of that team”. There is an art in positioning employees to achieve a personal excellence. Talent can also move too quickly without focusing on fundamentals. A good manager ensures a team is well-run in terms of quality of work, priorities, delegations, assignments, productivity etc.

If there’s an all-star team in your office which isn’t living up to its expectation, look into its management before making any changes. If you are putting together a new team, first hire the manager then the employees.

It’s easy to overlook subpar management, escpecially when they are surrounded by outstanding talent, but it’s not always easy to overcome.

18 views0 comments